Justitia (Scheibenriss)
unbestimmt
1520-1530
Thema des rundformatigen Scheibenrisses ist Justitia, die Personifikation der Gerechtigkeit und des Rechtswesens, die neben Prudentia (Klugheit), Temperantia (Mäßigung) und Fortitudo (Tapferkeit) zu den Kardinaltugenden, den seit der Antike etablierten vier Grundtugenden, zählt. In eine kunstvoll gefältelte Toga gehüllt, steht sie auf den Stiegen eines antikischen architektonischen Hintergrundes; in ihrer linken Hand hält sie eine Waage – Symbol ihres sorgfältigen Abwägens der Sachlage – empor, in ihrer Rechten ein Richtschwert. Die mit einer Binde bedeckten Augen verdeutlichen die Objektivität ihres Urteils, das gleichsam blind und daher unbestechlich erfolgt.
Kreide und Kohle dienten in den Niederlanden im 15. und frühen 16. Jahrhundert üblicherweise nur zum Vorskizzieren einer Komposition und wurden nach deren Vollendung mit Silberstift, Feder oder Pinsel wieder entfernt. Einzig Jan Gossaert scheint auch autonome Zeichnungen »met swarr crijt«, in schwarzer Kreide ausgeführt zu haben, wie es zu jener Zeit in Italien und Deutschland durchaus gebräuchlich war (vgl. 13341; siehe auch Ainsworth u. a. 2010, S. 97, mit Hinweis auf den entsprechenden Bericht in Karel van Manders Schilder-Boeck aus dem Jahr 1604).
Die Zuordnung des Blattes an Gossaert wurde in der Forschung kontrovers diskutiert und reichte bis zu Zuschreibungsversuchen an Bernard van Orley oder einen Künstler aus dem Kreis um Pieter Coecke van Aelst. In der Hamburger Kunsthalle (Inv. 23908; vgl. Stefes 2011) befindet sich ein technisch ähnlicher Scheibenriss einer Fortuna, der zwar ebenfalls aus dem Gossaert-Kreis, jedoch nicht vom selben Zeichner stammt.
Bosch, Bruegel, Rubens, Rembrandt. Meisterwerke der Albertina, hg. von K. A. Schröder und C. Metzger, Albertina, Wien, Ostfildern 2013, Abb. 31, S. 68.
Justitia, the personification of justice, is among
the four cardinal virtues conceptualized in antiquity,
along with Prudentia (wisdom), Temperantia
(moderation), and Fortitudo (courage). Together
with the theological virtues of Fides (faith), Caritas
(love of neighbor), and Spes (hope), they formed a
set of values for Christian ethical behavior. Justitia
occupied a special place in this canon since it
embodied not only justice but also jurisprudence,
making it directly related to the administration of
law. From the late fifteenth century to the French
Revolution, the highest court in the Burgundian-
Hapsburg Netherlands was the Grote Raad (Great
Council) of Mechelen. Courts had also been established
in many other localities since the Middle
Ages, and numerous town halls featured depictions
of punitive yet protective justice to demonstrate the
fairness of civic power structures.
In the present sheet, Justice is robed in an
artfully folded toga and stands on the steps of an
antique-style architectural structure. The edifice
frames her symmetrically and, along with her
expressively outstretched arms, lends a decidedly
theatrical note to the scene. She holds the raised
sword of judgment in her right hand and a pair of
scales in her left. The scales embody her careful
weighing of both sides of the evidence. The arm
of the scales is slanting, symbolizing law that is no
longer in balance. Justitia’s blindfolded eyes attest
to the objectivity of her judgment, which is arrived
at without regard for a person’s identity (as if blind),
and therefore impartially. All are the familiar
attributes of Justitia. Conversely, the skull upon
which she has placed her foot is a common emblem
of Vanitas—an unusual element in this context,
replacing the lawbook or serpent one would expect
to see. The skull symbolizes sin and its punishment
or an exhortation to repentance. In combination
with the threatening sword of justice, the skull at
Justitia’s feet is, not coincidentally, reminiscent of
the executioner. At the same time, it illustrates the
eternal triumph of righteous justice over death.
With its circular format, the scene is revealed to
be a preliminary design for a stained-glass roundel.
Glass painting flourished in the Netherlands during
the first half of the sixteenth century. Such smallscale
roundels, depicting moral scenes promoting
a virtuous life and actions, figured prominently in
both public and domestic spaces. The designs were
usually provided to specialized glassmakers for
crafting, and in fact, many design drawings were
never executed in glass but instead became prized
collector’s items.
Justitia’s expressive gestures, delicate posture,
and half-bared breast comprise a free adaptation
of Marcantonio Raimondi’s (c. 1470/82–1527/34)
Lucretia, as recognized by Winkler.1 However,
Winkler’s attribution of the drawing to Bernard
van Orley (1490–1542) is not widely accepted. In
more recent studies, the present drawing has been
associated with a group of round glass designs that
use the same technique and materials of black chalk
and white opaque watercolor on gray-tinted paper.
Some of these sheets have been attributed to Jan
Gossart (1478–1532) himself or to his circle. Chalk
and charcoal were widely used in Germany and Italy
during this period, but in the Netherlands they were
normally employed only in the preliminary studies
of a composition. After the work was completed,
the chalk or charcoal was removed by means of
silverpoint, pen, or brush. Only Gossart appears to
have executed independent drawings met swarr crijt
(in black chalk), as Karel van Mander (1548–1606)
emphasized in his biography of the artist.2
Four glass designs regarded as Gossart originals
were presumably executed in the 1520s and are
stylistically close to the present drawing.3 A
technically similar drawing of Fortuna is part of
the collection of the Hamburger Kunsthalle. It,
too, originated in the Gossart circle but was not
executed by the same artist.4 Since no glass roundel
containing the same Justitia motif has survived, the
drawing may not have been intended for translation
into glass. Instead, it was most likely a collector’s
item focused upon the virtue of justice in an
increasingly turbulent age.
1. Winkler 1913–14, no. 19. Marcantonio Raimondi, after Raffaelo
Santi, Lucretia, c. 1510/11, engraving. The Albertina copies
are: 21.4 x 13.3 cm, DG1970/420; 19.5 x 12.6 cm, DG 1970/419;
Bartsch 1802–21, 14:155, no. 192.
2. Alsteens 2010, 97, with reference to the corresponding
account in Karel van Mander’s 1604 Schilder-Boeck, 226r.
3. Alsteens in Ainsworth et al. 2010, 369–75, nos. 94–97.
4. Circle of Jan Gossart, Fortuna, 1520s, brush and black ink,
white opaque watercolor over black chalk, on dark‑graytinted
paper, 21.6 cm (diam.), Hamburger Kunsthalle,
Kupferstichkabinett, 23908; Ainsworth et al. 2010, 369–75,
no. 305; Stefes 2011, 246, no. 371.
Emily J. Peters, Laura M. Ritter (Hg.), AK Tales of the City. Drawing in the Netherlands from Bosch to Bruegel, Cleveland Museum of Art 9.10.2022 - 8.1.2023, New Haven 2022, Kat. Nr. 89
