Jan de Beer, Wurzel Jesse (obere Hälfte mit thronender Madonna) (Scheibenriss), Inv. Nr.: 32919
Wurzel Jesse (obere Hälfte mit thronender Madonna) (Scheibenriss)
Jan de Beer, Wurzel Jesse (obere Hälfte mit thronender Madonna) (Scheibenriss), Inv. Nr.: 32919
Credit: ALBERTINA, Wien Image: ALBERTINA, Wien

Wurzel Jesse (obere Hälfte mit thronender Madonna) (Scheibenriss)

Jan de Beer

um 1515-1520




Künstler:in (Antwerpen um 1475 - 1528 Antwerpen)
Dateum 1515-1520
Object TypeZeichnung
Object typeDrawing
Materials / TechniquesPinsel in Grau und Weiß, über schwarzer Kreide, auf braungrau grundiertem Papier
DimensionsRahmenaußenmaß: 229 × 70 × 8 cm
Blatt: 219 × 60,1 cm
CreditALBERTINA, Wien
Object number32919
Text

Notable in both their quality and size and placed

one above the other, these two monumental drawings

depict the family tree of Christ, conceived as

an actual tree growing from root upward.1 The tree

grows upon the shoulders of the figure of the forebear

Jesse, father of King David, who sits beneath

a richly decorated baldachin [28]. Above it, in [29],

Kings David and Solomon appear from the line of

the rulers of Israel who exemplify Christ’s royal descent.

At the very top, Mary sits enthroned with the

Christ Child in her lap. In this section of the work

the tree is transformed into a vine, an allusion to

Christ as “the true vine”2 of the Eucharist. The two

works’ attribution to Jan de Beer (1470/80–1528), the

leading representative of Antwerp Mannerism, is

certain. This attribution has been assigned because

of the expressiveness and gentle melancholy of

the faces, typical of De Beer, and because of their

stylistic proximity to his only fully signed drawing,

a sheet bearing studies of nine heads (see Porras’s

essay, fig. 18).

De Beer was born around 1475 near Antwerp,

presumably the son of the painter Claes de Beer. He

was recorded as a master in 1504 and was very successful

during his lifetime, his style wholly aligned

with Mannerism. He died in 1528 in his native city

and left behind two sons, one of whom was also a

painter and the other a glass painter.

In contrast to the conventional rendering of this

theme, the figure of Jesse in the Albertina sheet is

seated rather than recumbent. Comparative examples

exist in the early sixteenth century both in the

Netherlands and in the Lower Rhine,3 including

several Antwerp sculptures from the second decade

of the sixteenth century that were apparently based

on a common type.4 There, too, the tree trunk

grows through the architecture of the baldachin,

to which a parted curtain is attached. De Beer

clearly adopted this local iconographic element in

his composition. Other drawings from the Antwerp

Mannerists today in Berlin5 and London6 attest

that the seated-Jesse type was characteristic for

Antwerp. However, in the present sheet, Jesse’s eyes

are open and he looks downward, rather than sleeping

with his head supported by his hand, as was

customary. With his right hand he points toward the

roots, which dig into his shoulders like giant fingers

or appear to grow out of them, as if to further

emphasize that he is the origin of the (family) tree.

Additional kings and prophets were traditionally

part of the representation of the Tree of Jesse. Thus,

we may conclude that the present drawing depicts

the middle group of a larger family tree, the lateral

portions of which were either not preserved or never

executed. The dimensions of the whole composition,

which must have been approximately 4.5 meters

high and 2 meters wide, combined with the leading

marked in black chalk at regular intervals, allow

us to surmise that we are looking at a monumental

cartoon—the middle section of a lancet window with

multiple vertical sections (see [34]). The lowered

eyelids of Jesse, the younger king, Mary, and the

Christ Child suggest they look down as if from a

raised position.

No comparable original-size cartoons for stainedglass

windows—or for any purpose, for that matter—

are preserved in the Netherlands from this period.7

Sketches were generally executed as simple drawings

in black chalk or charcoal on a neutral ground,

not in the time-consuming chiaroscuro technique

on prepared colored paper standard for considerably

smaller, domestic stained-glass panes (see Porras’s

essay). These sheets’ refinement and precision of

execution are astounding. The drawings retain no

indication of color. Was the window intended to be

executed in grisaille? If so, then the cartoon was

presumably laid directly under the glass pane, and

the drawing directly transferred.8

In any case, we do not know whether the window

was ever actually created. De Beer is documented to

have received a commission for the design of a glass

window for the Cathedral of Our Lady in Antwerp,

putting him in line with artists like Dirck Vellert

(1480/85–1547) and Pieter Coecke van Aelst the Elder

(1502–1550), who also produced stained-glass windows

there (see [33]). Since a Tree of Jesse window

was often found in churches where the Virgin Mary

was the patron saint, the two present cartoons could

indeed have been intended for Antwerp’s cathedral.

However, only the side sections of a window by De

Beer with the monumental figures of Saints John the

Baptist and John the Evangelist survive, following

the loss of many panes amid the Great Fire of 1533.

Moreover, many windows fell victim to the iconoclastic

attacks of 1566.9 What remains today are the two

cartoons, vividly preserving the planned commission,

whose patron still awaits identification.

 

1. Isaiah 11:1–10.

2. John 15:1–6.

3. Lower Rhine artist, Tree of Jesse, c. 1500, tempera and oil

on wood, 116.6 x 186.6 cm, Rijksmuseum Twenthe, Enschede,

0035; organ from the church of Scheemda with depiction of the

root of Jesse, c. 1526 (painting formerly attributed to Jan Swart

van Groningen), oil on wood, 645 x 300 cm including tracery,

Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, BK-NM-8184.

4. Unknown Antwerp artist, Jesse, 1500–1520, oak, 58 x 28 cm,

Victoria & Albert Museum, London, Sculpture Collection,

A.33-1928; Paul Williamson, Netherlandish Sculpture 1450–1550

(London: Victoria & Albert Museum, 2002), 160. Further

examples: unknown Antwerp artist, Tree of Jesse, c. 1500,

polychrome painted main panel, high altar, St. Laurentius in

Bocholt, Antwerp; unknown Antwerp artist, Root of Jesse, 1500–

1525, oak, 42 cm (height), Foundation Jean van Caloen, Schloss

Loppen; unknown Antwerp artist, fragment of an altarpiece,

c. 1520, gilded wood, SS. Cosmas and Damian, Titz, Antwerp;

unknown Antwerp artist, Jesse, c. 1530, oak, Collection Rau, on

loan to Arp Museum Bahnhof Rolandseck. The comparisons

come from the author’s lecture “Ein monumentaler Scheibenriss

von Jan de Beer,” Albertina Museum, May 7, 2016. Independently

of this, Ewing (2016, 101, ill. 51) concludes that the De Beer

composition manifests parallels with contemporary Antwerp

sculptures of the Tree of Jesse.

5. Antwerp Mannerist, Tree of Jesse, c. 1515/20, pen and brown

ink, white heightening, on prepared gray paper, 40.4 x 26.8 cm,

Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen, Berlin, KdZ 12492.

6. Unknown Antwerp artist, Tree of Jesse, c. 1515, pen and black

ink, white heightening, on blue paper, 26.6 x 34.3 cm,

British Museum, London, 1895,0915.1005.

7. The only comparable extant works from this period are a

series of chalk cartoons formerly attributed to Lucas van Leyden

(1494–1533) or Pieter Dircksz. Crabeth (died c. 1542/52). Today,

these cartoons are housed in the archive of the Sint Janskerk in

Gouda; see Filedt Kok and Mijnlieff 2007.

8. For this method of working, see Ewing 2016, 99, with reference

to Caen 2009, 223.

9. In this regard, see also Ewing 2016, 97, who points out the

secularization and changing taste of the eighteenth century as

well as additional factors that contributed to the destruction of

many windows from the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries.

 

Emily J. Peters, Laura M. Ritter (Hg.), AK Tales of the City. Drawing in the Netherlands from Bosch to Bruegel, Cleveland Museum of Art 9.10.2022 - 8.1.2023, New Haven 2022, Kat. Nr. 28-29

Die beiden monumentalen Blätter (Inv. 32919, Inv. 32920) bildeten übereinandergestellt den Karton für den Mittelteil eines mehrbahnigen Lanzettfensters zum Thema der Wurzel Jesse: Der Stammbaum Christi ist in Form eines Baumes dargestellt, der aus der Figur Jesses, des Vaters von König David, emporwächst (Inv. 32920) und damit die königliche Abstammung Jesu verdeutlicht. Im oberen Teil der Komposition (Inv. 32919) erscheinen die Könige David und Salomo aus der Reihe der Herrscher Israels, darüber thront Maria mit dem Christuskind. Wohl als Hinweis auf Christus als den »rechten Weinstock« (Joh 15, 1 – 6) beziehungsweise auf die Eucharistie verwandelt sich der Baum in diesem Abschnitt in einen Weinstock.

Die in der für Scheibenrisse typischen Clair-obscur-Technik auf farbigem Grund ausgeführten Blätter sind in ihrer Größe und Qualität einzigartig. Ihre Zuschreibung an Jan de Beer, den führenden Vertreter der Antwerpener Manieristen, steht aufgrund der für ihn typischen ausdrucksstarken, leicht melancholischen Gesichter und der stilistischen Nähe zu seinen Londoner Kopfstudien (um 1515 – 1520; London, The British Museum, Department of Prints and Drawings, Inv. 1886,0706.7) außer Zweifel. Ob das Glasfenster tatsächlich ausgeführt wurde, ist ungewiss, doch finden sich Wurzel-Jesse-Fenster oftmals in Kirchen mit Marienpatrozinien. Vielleicht waren die Kartons für die Antwerpener Liebfrauenkirche bestimmt, wo sich heute noch zwei Apostelfenster nach Entwürfen Jan de Beers befinden.

Bosch, Bruegel, Rubens, Rembrandt. Meisterwerke der Albertina, hg. von K. A. Schröder und C. Metzger, Albertina, Wien, Ostfildern 2013, Abb. 21, S. 46.


Catalogue raisonné
  • Benesch 1928, 32a
  • Bibliography
  • Auktionskatalog Gutekunst Stuttgart, 1910, Lot.Nr. 197
  • Friedländer, Max in: Jahrbuch der Pr. Kunstslg, 36/1915, S. 76
  • Friedländer, Max: Die altniederl. Malerei, Berlin 1933, S.22/24, Nr.7
  • Jahrbuch der kunsthist. Sammlungen in Wien, Bd. 53, 1957, Abb. 8a, b S. 17
  • Die Weltkunst, Jg. 30, Nr. 5, 1960, S. 8 (Abb)
  • AK Antwerpen/Maastricht 2005, Nr. 35 (P. van den Brink)
  • AK Bosch, Bruegel, Rubens, Rembrandt. Meisterwerke der Albertina, hg. von K. A. Schröder und C. Metzger, Albertina, Wien, Ostfildern 2013, Nr. 21 (Eva Michel)
  • Dan Ewing, Gothic Renewal in Renaissance Antwerp, Turnhout 2016, S. 97-105
  • Cécile Scailliérez (Hg.), Francois Ier et l'Art des Pays-Bas, (Ausst. Kat. Musée du Louvre, Paris 2017/2018), Paris 2017, S. 92, Nr. 55 (P. van den Brink)
  • Peter van den Brink, In Pursuit of the Individual Hand. Jan de Beer as a Draughtsman, in: Dan Ewing/Peter van den Brink/Robert Wenley, "Truly Bright and Memorable". Jan de Beer’s Renaissance Altarpieces, London 2019, S. 29-30
  • Emily J. Peters, Laura M. Ritter (Hg.), AK Tales of the city. Drawing in the Netherlands from Bosch to Bruegel, Cleveland Museum of Art 9.10.2022 - 8.1.2023, New Haven 2022, Kat. Nr. 29
  • Emily J. Peters, Laura Ritter (Hg.), AK Bruegel und seine Zeit, Albertina 15.2.2023 – 24.5.2023, Wien, München 2023, Kat. 5, 6.
  • Provenance
  • Sammlung Henry Wellesley (1791–1866), Oxford
  • ab 25.06.1866 deren Auktion bei Sotheby's, London (Lugt Rep. 29221)
  • Sammlung Ambroise Firmin-Didot (1790–1876), Paris
  • ab 16.04.1877 deren Auktion bei Druot, Paris (Lugt. Rep. 37349)
  • Sammlung Adalbert Freiherr von Lanna (1836–1909), Prag
  • ab 06.05.1910 deren Auktion bei H. G. Gutekunst, Nr. 197 (als Hans von Kulmbach), Stuttgart
  • Sammlung Rudolf von Gutmann (1880–1966), Wien
  • 1938 Zentraldepot für beschlagnahmte Sammlungen, Wien
  • 1944 Dorotheum, Wien
  • 1944 Antiquariat August Maisgeyer, Wien
  • 1959 Albertina (Beschluss des Kunstrückgabebeirats 2012)
  • Online resources
    IIIF Logo IIIFPermalinkhttps://sammlungenonline.albertina.at/objects/32602/wurzel-jesse-obere-halfte-mit-thronender-madonna-scheibenImage Request
    Last edited25.10.2024